By Robert Berg
CULTURAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT--INSTALLATION Commander, U.S. Naval Forces, Marianas
Commander, U.S. Naval Forces, Marianas (COMNAVMARIANAS) is located in the U.S. Territory of Guam. The island is the largest and most southern island in the Mariana Islands archipelago. It is approximately 30 miles long, between four and eight miles wide and has a total land area of 212 square miles. COMNAVMARIANAS controls approximately 43,000 acres of land on Guam and in the Commonwealth of Northern Mariana Islands (CNMI), which includes Saipan, Tinian, Rota, and Farallon de Medinilla (FDM).
The geographic scope of the commander's responsibilities covers a portion of the western Pacific nearly as large as the United States. As regional area coordinator, COMNAVMARIANAS provides support to the operating forces of the 7th Fleet and to shore activities and members of U.S. Navy commands on Guam. This includes executive oversight of waterfront operations, ordnance and other logistics support. They provide policy support and services to shore activities and personnel of other naval facilities and their tenant commands in Guam, including a combined total of approximately 5800 active duty military, 2200 civilian, and 9100 family members.
In December 1898, Guam was ceded by Spain to the United States as part of the Treaty of Paris. The following year, U.S. Naval Station Guam was established with the entire island being designated as Naval Station. The Commanding Officer, Captain Leary, was designated as the Governor of Guam. Naval Station controlled Guam until it surrendered to Japan in December 1941, and the island remained under Japanese rule until July 21, 1944 when U.S. forces returned to liberate the island. From 1944 until 1952, Naval Station served as a naval operations base, providing every type of fleet service. In 1956, the Naval Base was disestablished and Naval Station was reassigned under the
military command of Commander, U.S. Forces Marianas.
Numerous Navy commands supporting the Pacific Fleet now call Guam “home.” As a result of a series of consolidations which took place during the 1990's, Naval Station, Naval Magazine, and Naval Activities were unified under Commander, U.S. Naval Forces, Marianas.
As a major landowner on the history-rich island of Guam, COMNAVMARIANAS is literally immersed in historic sites. COMNAVMARIANAS manages ancient Chamorro (prehistoric), Spanish-era, and World War II historical resources, historic structures, and submerged resources. Today, more than 55 years after the American recapture of the island from the Japanese, Guam retains the essential features of battlefield terrain and a surprisingly large number of physical reminders of the struggle, such as caves and fortifications, with a high degree of historical integrity. There are thousands of known terrestrial cultural resources on COMNAVMARIANAS. Over 34,000 acres of the COMNAVMARIANAS land inventory is included in Cultural Resources Management Planning documents.
BACKGROUND
COMNAVMARIANAS completed regionalization in October 1998, which included the consolidation of the Naval Activities; Naval Magazine; Communication Annexes, Finegayan and Barrigada; and Naval Hospital. Cultural Resources Management Plans (CRMPs) were completed for COMNAVMARIANAS prior to the most recent consolidation in August 1998, and a new comprehensive Integrated Cultural Resources Management Plan (ICRMP) is in development. The ICRMP will integrate the various cultural resource management plans and programs and will be completed after the final remaining cultural resources inventory is completed in early FY ‘03. Surveys of 1940 acres were
completed in FY ‘01. Final surveys for the remaining 770 acres of property were conducted in FY ‘02, and the final report on these surveys will be completed this year. The CRMP identifies cultural resources found on COMNAVMARIANAS, including sites, structures, features and objects. It evaluates them for nomination to the National Register of Historic Places (National Register), provides management maps of the cultural resources, and makes recommendations for the preservation of National Register eligible cultural resources.
Significant cultural resources on COMNAVMARIANAS include:
National Register since it is an excellent example of breakwater construction in the 1940s, and is mostly under local government control.
In the interest of sound cultural resources management, COMNAVMARIANAS has developed agreements with a variety of agencies. The following Programmatic Agreements and Memorandums of Agreement are currently in place:
On behalf of the Commander, U.S. Naval Forces, Marianas, the Environmental Division performs administrative, technical, and programmatic duties to ensure environmental compliance, cultural resources conservation and management, and effective environmental stewardship. COMNAVMARIANAS Environmental Staff is committed to providing exemplary stewardship of cultural resources by striving to enhance and protect historic and cultural resources while supporting COMNAVMARIANAS’ mission and complying with applicable environmental laws and regulations.
While the Environmental Division has only one full time employee with primary duties devoted to cultural and historic resources management, the leadership and support provided by the other staff and management of the division contributes tremendously to the many accomplishments in this arena. More noteworthy is the great support and leadership provided from COMNAVMARIANAS’ top leaders–Rear Admiral Patrick Dunne, Commander, U.S. Naval Forces, Marianas; Captain David Allen, Chief of Staff, and Captain Joseph Ludovici, Assistant Chief of Staff for Facilities and Environment.
Their personal emphasis on the program has encouraged the entire Navy family, including Force Judge Advocate, Public Affairs, Family Support Center, MWR, Seabees, and other installation organizations to actively participate in the protection of the rich historic and cultural resources on Guam and in the Mariana Islands.
There are a number of local committees and boards which have a direct impact on the Installation’s programs. These include the non-profit Marianas Military Museum Foundation, the Guam Historic Preservation Trust, Guam Historic Review Board, and the Department of Chamorro Affairs. COMNAVMARIANAS is fortunate in that Navy participation is encouraged and that the Cultural Resources Manager is an appointee to several of the organizations, serving to strengthen ties between the Navy and civilian community. Of particular note is the “Sister Village” program, wherein COMNAVMARIANAS partners with the Village of Santa Rita for cultural resources awareness and
actions.
The primary objective of COMNAVMARIANAS’ Cultural Resources Management program is to develop, protect, conserve and manage the historic and cultural resources. COMNAVMARIANAS works with the Guam State Historic Preservation Office, CNMI Historic Preservation Officer, and the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation to ensure training operations and base activities remain compatible with potential historic and cultural resources. To this end, COMNAVMARIANAS developed competencies in historic restoration, archeological surveys, historic and cultural management, assessment of the potential of impacting cultural or historic resources, and community relations. Each of these focused areas has been successful and will continue to have an impact on COMNAVMARIANAS’ Cultural Resources Management program. Several key projects during the award period illustrate the focused areas of the forthcoming ICRMP-core samples to analyze pollens in soils and used to determine historic activities at those sites, the discovery of the “correct” location of Ft. San Luis, and restoration of the Japanese Midget Submarine.
ACCOMPLISHMENTS
Cultural Resources Management is accomplished through a variety of resources such as the Legacy Resource Management Program funds; Operation and Maintenance, Navy (O&MN) funds; partnering with volunteer organizations, and through individual volunteers. Coordination, cooperation and planning with local and federal agencies and the general public are important keys to achieving success in cultural resources management.
Frequent communication and interaction with the regulatory agencies such as GSHPO has led to the concurrence of nearly 100 percent of all proposed actions and are especially noteworthy because a sizable amount of all Guam historical resources (Prehistoric and the WW II era) occur on COMNAVMARIANAS properties. Furthermore, the President’s Advisory Council has concurred with “No Adverse Effect” determinations submitted by COMNAVMARIANAS over the years.
Historic Buildings and Structures
The Sumay Cemetery was nominated for listing in the National Register for its association with events that made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of Guam’s history. Surviving the American invasion and the destruction of the village around it, the cemetery has retained its integrity of location, design, setting and feeling. Its excellent condition is attributable to, and a symbol of, the Chamorro traditional cultural values of respect for the dead and the support of the family and community.
The cemetery had deteriorated over time. In order to preserve and enhance the property, COMNAVMARIANAS initiated a restoration program for the cemetery in June 1996. Consultations with the Guam State Historic Preservation Office (GSHPO), Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, the National Park Service (NPS), and the Mayors of the Villages of Agat and Santa Rita ensured that the design for the project was compatible with the historic and architectural qualities of
the historic area. The Cemetery Enhancement Program was completed with great success and the cemetery was accepted for listing on the National Register in FY2000.
COMNAVMARIANAS has invested nearly $1 million for archeological surveys over the last three years. These surveys provide a detailed description, condition, and location of historic and cultural resources on COMNAVMARIANAS property. They are used during military training planning and execution to ensure impacts are kept at an insignificant level while providing for realistic training.
The following archaeological surveys were conducted during the past three years:
COMNAVMARIANAS is a responsible steward, and develops creative measures to maintain and preserve its archeological materials with the goal of making the resources available to the public. Archeological collections from COMNAVMARIANAS have migrated from being curated either inhouse or by contractors to civil authorities and facilities. MOA’s are in effect with the Governments of Guam and Tinian for transferring these assets to local museums and government organizations. This partnership between the Navy and local community will allow a more effective preservation of the resource at a reduced cost, and greater public access.
COMNAVMARIANAS incorporates environmental awareness into its base monthly indoctrination program which covers each major environmental program, including Cultural Resources Management. The cultural resources manager gives presentations for new personnel twice each month, and has given presentations to an additional 1200 military personnel during the past year alone. During planning and execution of training operations, troop awareness is heightened. For example, during the Tandem Thrust ’99 training event and Millennium Edge ‘02, COMNAVMARIANAS developed an environmental education video to introduce Guam’s unique environmental surrounding and identify the major environmental issues, particularly natural and cultural resources. In addition to the video, information cards were distributed which briefly describe environmental responsibilities, environment surroundings, environmental safeguards, and restrictions during all phases of Tandem Thrust ‘99 and Millennium Edge ‘02.
COMNAVMARIANAS personnel established the Command Historical Exhibit in 1994 to commemorate the 50TH Anniversary of the recapture of Guam by American Forces. Its location on the base provides a rich historical background. The Exhibit is located in Sumay Village, the location of the Transpacific Telephone Cable Station built in 1904. In 1921, the U.S. Marine Barracks was built in Sumay. In 1935, Pan Am China Clipper began service on the island. In 1941, Sumay was the first place on Guam to be bombed by the Japanese, within hours after making their strike on Pearl Harbor. The village is listed in the Guam Register of Historic Places.
The Gallery has been visited by more than 2,600 people during the past year, from 42 of the 50 states, and from 21 countries around the world. It is an excellent education facility, and hosts hundreds of school children per year. Many Japanese, including former World War II veterans and families, visit as often as annually. Two years ago and again in FY ‘02, the Gallery was visited by Mrs. Yoshio Iwanami, granddaughter of Japanese War Minister, Tojo. The widow of Sgt. Shoichi Yokoi, the last Japanese holdout on Guam, also visited. The son of Admiral Yamaguchi, Commanding Officer of the aircraft carrier Hiryu, lost at Midway, visited with Mrs. Iwanami. The non-profit corporation Marianas Military Museum Foundation has established a web site dedicated to the Gallery at
www.guam.net/pub/milmuseum. Overall visitation annually averages 4,500 people.
As demonstrated during Tandem Thrust ‘99 and Millennium Edge ‘02, environmental awareness and protection are important considerations particularly in COMNAVMARIANAS operational areas where there is a unique collection of cultural and historic communities. Constraints are established to protect areas of cultural significance from impacts caused by the training exercise. These constraints include:
Environmental monitors are assigned and given authority to temporarily halt or modify any exercise activity causing an immediate threat to any cultural resource.
All the efforts mentioned above play an important role in enhancing the accomplishment of the command’s mission. The goal for COMNAVMARIANAS with respect to military training and operations is to ensure that the Navy maintains its access to air, sea, and land resources through an effective cultural resources stewardship program within its operational areas not only on Guam but within the CNMI as well. To help achieve this, COMNAVMARIANAS completed an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for military training in the Marianas in July 1999.
The EIS evaluated potential environmental impacts of all ongoing and long-range training activities in the Mariana Islands that are required by the Commander, U.S. Pacific Command. Coupled with the Environmental Assessment for the joint military training exercise Tandem Thrust '99 (TT99), Commander, U.S. Pacific Command forces can now conduct a variety of recurring and large-scale training operations, such as this year’s Millennium Edge ‘02, in the Mariana Islands to maintain essential military capabilities, demonstrate combat readiness, and assure responsiveness to crises in the region, while also protecting cultural resources.
Military bases on Guam have experienced a tremendous amount of change and restructuring. The closing and downsizing of military bases on Guam and the recent increases in mission and operations have placed a heavy burden on COMNAVMARIANAS with respect to new construction and consolidation of duties. In spite of this, COMNAVMARIANAS continues to place protection and enhancement of the island’s cultural resources as a top priority. The COMNAVMARIANAS Environmental Office interacts regularly with the GSHPO, Advisory Council, Guam Preservation Trust, Department of Chamorro Affairs, and other local and federal agencies as required. Interagency communication on sensitive aspects of all projects ensures compliance.
Tandem Thrust ‘99 and Millennium Edge ‘02 demonstrated that through advanced planning and partnering with other military organizations, and state and federal agencies, the mission can be carried out without adverse impacts to the island’s historic and cultural resources.
The history of the Mariana Islands is rich and unique. COMNAVMARIANAS has proven to be a true steward in the protection and preservation of this unique culture without jeopardizing its mission.